Hall's Logo

Order your Easter pies today!

(716) 434-0838

Learn about all the pies we offer.

    • Apple

    • Apple Caramel Walnut

    • Apple Crumb

    • Blackberry

    • Blueberry

    • Cherry

    • Cherry Crumb

    • Elderberry

    • Mince

    • Mixed Berry

    • Peach

    • Red Raspberry

    • Rhubarb

    • Strawberry Rhubarb

    • Banana

    • Butterscotch

    • Chocolate

    • Coconut

    • Key Lime

    • Lemon Meringue

    • Peanut Butter

    • Chocolate Peanut Butter

    • Custard

    • Pecan

    • Pumpkin

    • Butter Tarts

  • Our standard size pies are 10 inches, and serve 6-8 people.

    We also offer a smaller, 6 inch pie.

  • We make a selection of fresh pies daily, but to guarantee you get the kind of pie you desire, it’s best to call ahead and order.

  • We offer both.

    Our standard size pies are available fresh and frozen, with the exception of cream pies. We don’t freeze our cream pies.

    With frozen pies, we offer them unbaked and already baked. Unbaked pies will need to be fully baked at home, and the already baked pies just need to be defrosted.

    Our 6-inch pies are only available fresh.